Foundations of Joy
The Torah ends with three pesukim which are a sweeping tribute to the greatness of Moshe and his unique and lasting accomplishments. The last words of the tribute are, “which Moses performed before the eyes of all Israel.” Rashi tells us this refers to when Moshe broke the luchot. This last comment of Rashi’s on the Torah takes us back to a moment of national disgrace, but also paradoxically, to a moment of healing. Moshe received a yasher koach from Hashem for his decision to smash the luchot. Reish Lakish, the ultimate baal teshuva, comments on this that there are times when Torah is established only through a process of bitul, of negation (Menachot 99a).
This is an amazingly fitting and powerful message for this time of year. These thoughts of brokenness and repair accompany us as we finish our yearly reading of the Torah, the cycle of chagim in Tishrei and the cycle of the shalosh regalim. Years ago in the desert, the broken luchot were placed into the aron alongside the new luchot we received on Yom Kippur. When we marched forward as a nation into Eretz Yisrael, we were carrying them both together. The second luchot were born from the broken shards of the first luchot, just as today the joy of Sukkot is born from our brokenness on Yom Kippur, and our success in the new year is built on our ability to absorb and accept not just our successes but also the failures of the year we are leaving behind.
This idea takes on more depth through Rav Schorr’s beautiful explanation of the deeper meaning of the nisuch hamayim, the water drawing ceremony which took place when the Beit Hamikdash was standing. During the nisuch hamayim, the nation would gather together in the courtyard every night, singing and dancing with unparalleled joy until daybreak. Afterward, a procession would gather water from the Shiloach spring. The water would be poured on the altar together with the wine libation of the morning offering.
Rashi (Vayikra 2:13) explains that the spiritual origins of this ceremony began during the time of creation, when the lower waters were separated from the higher waters, causing them to cry out to Hashem, “we too want to stand before the King!” One way Hashem consoled the waters was that they would be part of the nisuch hamayim ceremony. However, as Rav Shorr points out, it was a very ironic consolation. The water of the nisuch hamayim was poured down the holes in the alter, to the shittin, the empty space under the alter, and from there fell all the way back down to the depths from whence they came. What type of consolation was this?
To answer, Rav Schorr looks more deeply into the meaning of the shittin, the empty space into which the waters fell. This empty space was originally formed when Hashem gathered up earth for the creation of man. It was the empty space left in the land from the creation of man. It was also the place where Adam offered his first Korban and the place where Avraham brought Yitzchak to the Akeidah. As Rambam writes, “Man was created from the place of his atonement (Hilchot Beit HaBechirah 2:2).” The shittin symbolizes the empty space Hashem carves out to make room for evil in the world. In other words, it is the place of our bechira, our free will, the place where Hashem’s presence is hidden enough for us to be able to have a real choice between good and bad. It is the place where evil appears real.
Our bechira is born from our separation from Hashem, and so the pain of the lower waters is our pain was well. From the moment of our creation as independent beings, we too have been crying out that we want to stand before Hashem. When we pour out the water of the nisuch hamayim, and at the same time “pour out our hearts like water before Hashem (Eicha 2:19),” the action becomes the kli, the vessel, to return both the water and ourselves to our source. On a deeper level, when we use our bechira to reveal Hashem in this world we are able to lift the curtain. We reveal that Hashem’s presence is really everywhere. Even in the depths we are still “standing before the King.” The water of the nisuch hamayim physically descends but spiritually rises.
This is the experience we take with us into Shmini Azteret. The Sfat Emet tells us that each of the Shalosh Regalim relate to one of the Avot: Avraham to Pesach, Yitzchak to Shavout and Yaacov to Sukkot. Shmini Atzeret is the holiday of Yosef. Like Yosef, who was sometimes considered an Av and sometimes considered a shevet, it has a bit of a duality. Shmini Atzeret is in some ways part of Sukkot, and in some ways stands on its own.
Yosef was the tzaddik who learned the lessons of Yom Kippur and applied them to life. He understood the real meaning of forgiveness, which is not necessarily what we might assume. When we say to Hashem, “Forgiveness is with you (Tehillim 130:4),” Malbim tells us that this is literal. Forgiving in the sense of making the wrong as if it didn’t happen is an attribute of Hashem. When someone has truly wronged us, we cannot make it as if it never happened. If we try we will often find ourselves, years after an event, triggered and angry about something we thought we forgave so long ago. For this reason, there is no instance of one person forgiving another in Tanach. Instead, there is something different, something that is exemplified by Yosef.
This is a point Rabbanit Yemima Mizrachi makes eloquently in her book about Yom Kippur. Rabbanit Mizrachi explains that the Torah asks us not to forgive but to make peace. When the brothers came to ask for forgiveness, his response was, “You intended to harm me, but G-d intended it for good, to accomplish what is now being done—the salvation of many lives (Bereisheit 50:20).”
“Joseph teaches us the meaning of true reconciliation. It is not about making our peace with evil and with evildoers, but about making our peace with what happened and where it led us. It is about being able to say to G-d, ‘Master of the Universe, from this degradation and loss of dignity, I have found salvation…It is about recognizing how everything that happened to us can make the world better for others, without destroying us.” (Yearning to Return, p.137)
Our sukkah is a sukkah of peace. It is the time when we make peace not just with others, but with all the events of our own lives, and with ourselves. As the Ohr Gedalyahu points out, at that moment when Yosef made peace with the brothers, they experienced a complete shift in their perception. They had been interacting with the King of Egypt. They had been facing the enemy. And then the enemy was revealed to be their brother, the brother they had thrown out, but who was willing to make peace with them anyway. The entire world as they understood it shifted. The empty space of evil was revealed to be the place of the revelation of Hashem.
Yosef’s name is given two meanings in Tanach. It means both gathering in and adding (Bereisheit 30:23-24). Shmini Atzeret, the last day of chag, the day of Yosef, is a day of this two-fold avodah. We gather in all that we have accomplished, including all of our failings. We recognize that just as the ark carries both the broken luchot and the new luchot, we can carry together, in unity, both our successes and our failures. From that place we can move forward and add.
The Sfat Emet (בראשונה”” (תרלו tells us that this is why Sukkot comes after Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur. On Yom Kippur we are all baalei teshuva. We feel that we have no place in the world. However, if we can create no place for ourselves from our own strength, Hashem steps in and gives us a place. And the place Hashem gives us is a better, higher place than we could earn on our own. “In the place where baalei teshuva stand, the perfectly righteous are not able to stand (Brachot 34b),” because baalei teshuva stand in a place that was given to them as a gift from heaven.
Our sukkah is a gift of place from God. We sit in it during the holiday of the harvest, and at the time when the entire world is gathering in the harvest, we do a personal harvest. We gather in our actions over the last 40 days and take the time to absorb the results of our spiritual activities, unifying them, and allowing them to take root in our soul, so that we can use them as a source of joy for the entire year. We can take the time to recognize the value of both our successes and our mistakes. The joy of Sukkot is built on a recognition that Hashem loves us and created us imperfect, so that we could have free will. The process is everything. Every mistake, every place of emptiness, is a precious foundation stone for growth and joy.